Matching evaluation of supply chain procurement models for agricultural machinery products and services

doi:10.13733/j.jcam.issn.2095-5553.2024.08.045

Abstract

Abstract: With the digital transformation of the manufacturing industry and the application of the supply chains of agricultural machinery products and services， there arises subjectivity and ambiguity in selecting the matching process for agricultural machinery manufacturing enterprises􀆳 product parts procurement mode. To address this， a procurement mode matching evaluation method is proposed based on matter‑element extension superiority， combined with the extension analytic hierarchy process and the CRITIC comprehensive empowerment method. From the agricultural machinery manufacturing enterprise􀆳s own characteristics and product service supply chain influencing factors as the entry point， the agricultural machinery manufacturing equipment procurement mode matching evaluation system is constructed under the perspective of the product service supply chain， and through the correlation function calculation， the comprehensive superiority ranking of procurement mode is obtained and the correlation degree comparison of single indexes is compared， and the optimal procurement matching mode and mode identification degree are output. The results show that the optimal procurement model matching degree is 0.118， and the corresponding model can be used as the core procurement model in the production， supply， and marketing stages. Example calculations show that the established evaluation model has a high degree of matching with the enterprise， which proves that the method combines qualitative prediction and quantitative decision‑making and can provide a systematic and scientific matching tool for the product procurement model of agricultural machinery manufacturing enterprises.

Key words: agricultural machinery, product service supply chain, matter?element extension method, sourcing model matching, indicator system

摘要： 随着制造业数字化转型和农机产品服务供应链的应用，突显出农机制造企业产品零部件采购模式，在选择匹配过程中存在主观性与模糊性的问题，提出一种基于物元可拓优度结合可拓层次分析法和CRITIC综合赋权法的采购模式匹配评价方法。从农机制造企业产品自身特征和产品服务供应链影响因素为切入点，构建产品服务供应链视角下的农机制造装备采购模式匹配评价体系，并通过关联函数计算，得到采购模式综合优度排序和单项指标的关联度对比，输出最优采购匹配模式和模式识别度。结果表明，最优采购模式匹配度为0.118，所对应的模式可以作为产供销阶段的核心采购模式。实例计算表明，建立的评价模型与企业匹配度很高，该方法将定性预测和定量决策结合起来，可以为农机制造企业的产品采购模式提供系统科学的匹配工具。

关键词: 农机机械, 产品服务供应链, 物元可拓方法, 采购模式匹配, 指标体系

CLC Number:

F272.3
N945

Xiong Zonghui, , He Zhiqi, Hu Pingping, Cao Dongsheng. Matching evaluation of supply chain procurement models for agricultural machinery products and services [J]. Journal of Chinese Agricultural Mechanization, 2024, 45(8): 308-316.

熊宗慧, 何志琪, 胡平平, 曹东升. 面向农机产品服务供应链采购模式匹配评价[J]. 中国农机化学报, 2024, 45(8): 308-316.

References

[ 1 ] 周尚豪，熊宗慧，王冰涛. 基于物元可拓法的农机制造企业核心竞争力提升[J]. 中国农机化学报， 2023， 44（9）: 265-273.
Zhou Shanghao， Xiong Zonghui， Wang Bingtao. Improving the core competitiveness of agricultural machinery manufacturing enterprises based on Matter‑Element extension method [J]. Journal of Chinese Agricultural Mechanization， 2023， 44（9）: 265-273.
[ 2 ] 孙道贺，杨欣，魏津瑜. 基于工业互联网的农机供应链多边匹配问题研究[J]. 中国农机化学报， 2021， 42（9）: 130-135.
Sun Daohe， Yang Xin， Wei Jinyu. Research on the multilateral matching of agricultural machinery supply chain based on industrial Internet [J]. Journal of Chinese Agricultural Mechanization， 2021， 42（9）: 130-135.
[ 3 ] 刘智焕. 供应链背景下的采购模式调整和流程优化研究[J]. 鄂州大学学报， 2017， 24（6）: 40-42.
[ 4 ] 郑浩昊，李思. 基于综合因素考虑的联合采购利益分配模式研究[J]. 价值工程， 2016， 35（12）: 7-10.
Zheng Haohao， Li Si. Research on the benefit allocation model of joint procurement based on comprehensive factors [J]. Value Engineering， 2016， 35（12）: 7-10.
[ 5 ] 许磊，郭顺生，胡烈锋，等. 建材装备制造业原材料采购供应商选择评价研究[J]. 数字制造科学， 2017， 15（3）: 129-134.
Xu Lei， Guo Shunsheng， Hu Liefeng， et al. Study on the selection and assessment of purchaser and supplier of raw materials for building materials and equipment manufacturing industry [J]. Digital Manufacturing Science， 2017， 15（3）: 129-134.
[ 6 ] Li M， Mizuno S. Dynamic pricing and inventory management of a dual‑channel supply chain under different power structures [J]. European Journal of Operational Research， 2022， 303（1）: 273-285.
[ 7 ] 吴中富，曹国忠，刘帅，等. 基于流的产品创新原理解评价方法研究[J]. 机械设计与研究， 2017， 33（5）: 1-5， 15.
Wu Zhongfu， Cao Guozhong， Liu Shuai， et al. Research on evaluation method of product innovation principle solution based on flow [J]. Machine Design and Research， 2017， 33（5）: 1-5， 15.
[ 8 ] 曹倩倩，楼志斌，余文兵，等. 采用可拓方法的竞价采购模式匹配研究[J]. 现代制造工程， 2013（9）: 45-49.
Cao Qianqian， Lou Zhibin， Yu Wenbing， et al. Research of model matching on bidding procurement based on the extension method [J]. Modern Manufacturing Engineering， 2013（9）: 45-49.
[ 9 ] 陈伟伟. 基于层次分析法和模糊综合评价法的高值医用耗材管理软件采购评价方法研究[D]. 南京: 东南大学， 2021.
[10] 梁展，狄娜，裴铮. 基于模糊综合评价的装备采购评价指标与方法研究[J]. 物流技术， 2018， 37（1）: 145-149.
Liang Zhan， Di Na， Pei Zheng.Research on evaluation indexes and methods of equipment purchase based on fuzzy comprehensive evaluation [J]. Logistics Technology， 2018， 37（1）: 145-149.
[11] Wijaya E R， Rudianto. Selection of supplier for the evaluation of procurement of special chemical using entropy method and topsis in xyz company [J]. IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering， 2020， 909（1）: 012046.
[12] Chou T Y， Liao J P. Using MEC and FAHP to establish an evaluation model for food processing machinery procurement [J]. Mathematical Problems in Engineering， 2020.
[13] 张晓娜，杨玉中，高学鸿. 基于改进AHP和GRA煤炭企业采购绩效评价研究[J]. 物流科技， 2015， 38（12）: 119-123.
Zhang Xiaona， Yang Yuzhong， Gao Xuehong. Research on coal enterprise􀆳s procurement performance evaluation based on improved AHP and GRA [J]. Logistics Sci‑Tech， 2015， 38（12）: 119-123.
[14] Smeltzer L R， Carr A. Electronic reverse auctions: Promises， risks and conditions for success [J]. Industrial Marketing Management， 2003， 32（6）: 481-488.
[15] George J， Pillai V M. Evaluation of inventory replenishment policies on supply chain performance with grey relational analysis [J]. International Journal of Integrated Supply Management， 2021， 14（2）: 197-227.
[16] George J， Pillai V M. Supply chain performance evaluation using spreadsheet simulation [J]. Applied Mechanics and Materials， 2014， 592-594: 2699-2703.
[17] 何杜博，黄栋. 基于改进EAHP的装备采购供应链质量绩效评价[J]. 运筹与管理， 2022， 31（2）: 148-154.
He Dubo， Huang Dong. Equipment procurement supply chain quality performance evaluation based on improved EAHP [J]. Operations Research and Management Science， 2022， 31（2）: 148-154.
[18] Tan Yuyang， Zhao Wenchao， Guo Chunxiang. The joint procurement model and algorithm for small and medium enterprises [J]. Computers & Industrial Engineering， 2021， 155: 107179.
[19] Hosseini S， Morshedlou N， Ivanov D， et al. Resilient supplier selection and optimal order allocation under disruption risks [J]. International Journal of Production Economics， 2019， 213: 124-137.
[20] Smeltzer L R， Carr A S. Electronic reverse auctions: Promises， risks and conditions for success [J]. Industrial Marketing Management， 2003， 32（6）: 481-488.
[21] Butdee S， Nitnara C. A fuzzy logic combined with LP model for performance evaluation to distribute purchase orders in cluster manufacturing [J]. Procedia Manufacturing， 2019， 30: 19-25.
[22] 伍俊舟，王玫，袁敏. 基于模糊可拓层次分析法的机电产品再制造性评价方法及应用[J]. 组合机床与自动化加工技术， 2016（9）: 153-156.
Wu Junzhou， Wang Mei， Yuan Min.Evaluation method and application of mechanical and electrical products' remanufacture‑ability based on fuzzy‑EAHP [J]. Modular Machine Tool & Automatic Manufacturing Technique， 2016（9）: 153-156.
[23] 戴宁，万林林. 基于组合赋权TOPSIS模型的工艺参数决策方法[J]. 机械制造与自动化， 2022， 51（4）: 107-112.
Dai Ning， Wan Linlin. Decision making method of process parameters based on TOPSIS model with combination weight [J]. Machine Building & Automation， 2022， 51（4）: 107-112.
[24] 徐淑珍，熊宗慧，袁逸萍，等. 基于EAHP的农机供应链服务质量评价应用[J]. 中国农机化学报， 2021， 42（1）: 166-172.
Xu Shuzhen， Xiong Zonghui， Yuan Yiping， et al. Application of agricultural machinery supply chain service quality evaluation based on EAHP [J]. Journal of Chinese Agricultural Mechanization， 2021， 42（1）: 166-172.

[1]	Shen Weijie, Xiao Maohua, Song Xinmin, Xiang Tengfei. Fault diagnosis of agricultural machinery rolling bearing based on CNN—SVM by continuous wavelet transform#br# [J]. Journal of Chinese Agricultural Mechanization, 2025, 46(4): 254-264.
[2]	Wu Haifeng, Zhang Xuejun, Shi Zenglu, Cheng Jinpeng, Yu Yongliang. Design and experiment of a top bar clamping-type maize precision seed-metering device [J]. Journal of Chinese Agricultural Mechanization, 2025, 46(3): 11-18.
[3]	Li Mingliang, Pu Juan, Kong Rong, Yu Guoxin, Zhao Lanlan. Impact of conservation tillage machinery on green total factor productivity of grain: Based on a dualcarbon perspective [J]. Journal of Chinese Agricultural Mechanization, 2025, 46(3): 285-294.
[4]	Li Daohe, Long Pei, Chen Jianghua. Impact of agricultural machinery socialized services on the “grain-oriented” planting structure： An analysis base on CLDS data [J]. Journal of Chinese Agricultural Mechanization, 2025, 46(3): 305-314.
[5]	Mei Yundong, Liu Lina, Dai Jun, Liu Haina, Tian Xiaoguang. Optimized allocation method of agricultural machinery service resources based on genetic algorithm [J]. Journal of Chinese Agricultural Mechanization, 2025, 46(3): 323-327.
[6]	He Dengke, He Puming, Wei Junying, Tian Hongyu. Study on the impact of agricultural machinery service outsourcing on farmers' income [J]. Journal of Chinese Agricultural Mechanization, 2025, 46(2): 337-343.
[7]	Dai Yizheng, Cheng Wenbin, Wang Junjun, Zhang Feibin, Xiong Huilan, Chen Huazhai. Orthogonal experiment study on uniformity of rice air-blowing centralized distributor [J]. Journal of Chinese Agricultural Mechanization, 2025, 46(1): 1-7.
[8]	Wang Xiaowei, Wang Huiqiang, Zhang Yong, Li Wenxiang , Sun Yulin, Sun Guangjun. Design and experiment of single ridge onion combine harvester [J]. Journal of Chinese Agricultural Mechanization, 2025, 46(1): 44-51.
[9]	Liu Minji, Wang Jiannan, Wang Ni, You Zhaoyan, Xie Huanxiong. Experiments and key parameters optimization of chain-plate huller for ginkgo nuts [J]. Journal of Chinese Agricultural Mechanization, 2025, 46(1): 105-111.
[10]	Zou Zhaobin. Generation and operation mechanism of the “unmanned agricultural machinery” service market [J]. Journal of Chinese Agricultural Mechanization, 2025, 46(1): 307-313.
[11]	Liu Wei, Liu Yuanyuan. Research on the measurement of regional technological innovation competitiveness on intelligent agricultural machinery industry based on patent analysis [J]. Journal of Chinese Agricultural Mechanization, 2024, 45(9): 311-317.
[12]	Yang Fan, , Teng Li, Sun Yitian, , Sun Yongjia, , Jiang Zhenhan, Hou Jialin. Development status and prospect of intelligent chassis of agricultural machinery [J]. Journal of Chinese Agricultural Mechanization, 2024, 45(8): 138-147.
[13]	Yu Chunhui, Chang Shuhui, , Zhang Fan, , Yao Jingfa, Meng Yu, Guo Yaqian. 面向大规模农田的农机跨区作业紧急调配研究 [J]. Journal of Chinese Agricultural Mechanization, 2024, 45(8): 196-203.
[14]	Qian Junnan, Feng Sang, Li Hang, Zhang Yong. Research on path tracking control algorithm of agricultural machinery based on extended Kalman filter [J]. Journal of Chinese Agricultural Mechanization, 2024, 45(7): 215-221.
[15]	Shan Haiyong, Yan Yini, Zhang Jin, Liu Xujie, Han Xiao, Liu Jian. Research progress on mechanization of soybean-corn belt composite planting [J]. Journal of Chinese Agricultural Mechanization, 2024, 45(6): 42-52.