农业产业组织模式研究回顾与展望

doi:10.13733/j.jcam.issn.2095‑5553.2024.08.046

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 在新发展阶段下，构建中国特色农业产业组织与组织体系是加快推进农业农村现代化，实现小农户与现代农业有机衔接，促进农业高质量发展的重要途径。对农业产业组织模式的内涵与理论基础、类型与演化、选择农业产业组织模式的影响因素及其经济效应等方面进行全面的回顾，为进一步提高农业产业组织模式发展中相关利益主体间协同互动和价值实现，提供理论支持与经验参考。按照“模式特征—影响因素—组织绩效”的内在逻辑，运用文献综述法和总结归纳法对相关研究进行综述。现有文献对农业产业组织模式进行系统研究，涵盖农业产业组织模式的内涵与类型，选择农业产业组织模式的行为机制和影响因素及其异质性影响，以及农业产业组织模式的选择效应及其差异化影响等方面。未来应创新关于农业产业组织模式分类的细化研究；进一步完善农业产业组织模式与区域协调性和经济适应性的研究；构建多学科交叉融合下的农业产业组织模式研究新范式。

关键词: 农业产业组织模式, 纵向一体化, 公司+农户, 产业组织理论, 交易费用

Abstract: Under the new development stage， the construction of agricultural industrial organization and organizational system with Chinese characteristics is an important way to accelerate the modernization of agriculture and rural areas， realize the organic connection between small farmers and modern agriculture， and promote high‑quality agricultural development. The article aims to provide a comprehensive review of the connotation and theoretical basis of the agricultural industrial organization model， its types and evolution， the influencing factors of selecting the agricultural industrial organization model and its economic effects. It provides theoretical support and empirical reference to further improve the synergistic interaction and value realization among relevant interest subjects in the development of agricultural industrial organization model. According to the internal logic of “model characteristics‑influencing factors‑organizational performance”， the literature review method and the summarization method are used to review the relevant studies. The existing literature has systematically studied agricultural industrial organization models， covering the connotation and types of agricultural industrial organization models， the behavioral mechanisms and influencing factors of selecting agricultural industrial organization models and their heterogeneous effects， as well as the selection effects of agricultural industrial organization models and their differentiated effects. In the future， we should innovate the refined research on the classification of agricultural industrial organization models， further improve the research on the coordination and economic adaptability of agricultural industrial organization models with regions， and build a new paradigm for the study of agricultural industrial organization under the combination of multiple disciplines.

Key words: , agricultural industry organization model, vertical integration, company and peasant household, industrial organization theory, transaction cost

中图分类号:

F320.1

梁远, 毕文泰, 张越杰, . 农业产业组织模式研究回顾与展望[J]. 中国农机化学报, 2024, 45(8): 317-324.

Liang Yuan, , Bi Wentai, Zhang Yuejie, . Review and prospect of agricultural industry organization model research [J]. Journal of Chinese Agricultural Mechanization, 2024, 45(8): 317-324.

参考文献

[ 1 ] 廖祖君，郭晓鸣. 中国农业经营组织体系演变的逻辑与方向: 一个产业链整合的分析框架[J]. 中国农村经济， 2015(2): 13-21.
[ 2 ] 黄祖辉. 改革开放四十年: 中国农业产业组织的变革与前瞻[J]. 农业经济问题， 2018(11): 61-69.
Huang Zuhui. Forty years of reform and opening up: Transformation and prospect of agricultural industrial organization in China [J]. Issues in Agricultural Economy， 2018(11): 61-69.
[ 3 ] 丰志培，常向阳. 中药材产业组织模式选择的影响因素分析——基于安徽省中药饮片企业的实证研究[J]. 农业技术经济， 2010(5): 55-63.
[ 4 ] 黄祖辉，王祖锁. 从不完全合约看农业产业化经营的组织方式[J]. 农业经济问题， 2002(3): 28-31.
[ 5 ] 程华，卢凤君，谢莉娇. 农业产业链组织的内涵、演化与发展方向[J]. 农业经济问题， 2019(12): 118-128.
Cheng Hua， Lu Fengjun， Xie Lijiao. Connotation， evolution and development direction of agricultural industry chain organization in China [J]. Issues in Agricultural Economy， 2019(12): 118-128.
[ 6 ] 李霖，郭红东. 产业组织模式对农户种植收入的影响——基于河北省、浙江省蔬菜种植户的实证分析[J]. 中国农村经济， 2017(9): 62-79.
[ 7 ] 张天柱，詹建臻，周磊，等. 现代农业产业园农民与合作社合约选择研究[J]. 中国农机化学报， 2022， 43(3): 185-195.
Zhang Tianzhu， Zhan Jianzhen， Zhou Lei， et al. Research on the contract selection between farmers and cooperatives in modern agricultural industrial park [J]. Journal of Chinese Agricultural Mechanization， 2022， 43(3): 185-195.
[ 8 ] 严成樑. 现代经济增长理论的发展脉络与未来展望——兼从中国经济增长看现代经济增长理论的缺陷[J]. 经济研究， 2020， 55(7): 191-208.
Yang Chengdong. Modern growth theory: Development， evolutionary logic， shortcomings and future prospects [J]. Economic Research Journal， 2020， 55(7): 191-208.
[ 9 ] Mighell R L， Jones L A. Vertical coordination inagriculture [M]. Farm Economics Division， Economic Research Service， US Department of Agriculture， 1963.
[10] Benmehaia M A， Brabez F. Vertical relationships and food supply chain coordination: The case of processing tomato sector in Algeria [J]. New Medit: Mediterranean Journal of Economics， Agriculture and Environment， 2018， 17(2): 3-14.
[11] 胡定寰，陈志钢，孙庆珍，等. 合同生产模式对农户收入和食品安全的影响——以山东省苹果产业为例[J]. 中国农村经济， 2006(11): 17-24.
[12] 汤吉军，戚振宇，李新光. 农业产业化组织模式的动态演化分析——兼论农业产业化联合体产生的必然性[J]. 农村经济， 2019(1): 52-59.
Tang Jijun， Qi Zhenyu， Li Xinguang. Dynamic evolution analysis of agricultural industrialization organization model [J]. Rural Economy， 2019(1): 52-59.
[13] 苑鹏. “公司+合作社+农户”下的四种农业产业化经营模式探析——从农户福利改善的视角[J]. 中国农村经济， 2013(4): 71-78.
[14] Lawrence J D， Hayenga M L. The US pork and beef sectors: Divergent organizational patterns， paradoxes and conflicts [J]. Paradoxes in Food Chains and Networks， 2002(1): 512-521.
[15] 李英，张越杰. 基于质量安全视角的稻米生产组织模式选择及其影响因素分析——以吉林省为例[J]. 中国农村经济， 2013(5): 68-77.
[16] 江光辉，胡浩. 农业企业纵向一体化契约模式选择及动态演变:基于生猪养殖企业的案例分析[J]. 南京农业大学学报(社会科学版)， 2022， 22(3): 164-176.
Jiang Guanghui， Hu Hao. Agricultural enterprises' vertical integration contract mode selection and dynamic evolution: Case analysis based on the pig breeding industry [J]. Journal of Nanjing Agricultural University (Social Sciences Edition)， 2022， 22(3): 164-176.
[17] 丁存振，肖海峰. 交易特性、农户产业组织模式选择与增收效应——基于多元Logit模型和MTE模型分析[J]. 南京农业大学学报(社会科学版)， 2019， 19(5): 130-142.
Ding Cunzhen， Xiao Haifeng. Transaction characteristics， farmers' industrial organization model selection and income growth: An analysis based on multivariate Logit model and MTE model [J]. Journal of Nanjing Agricultural University (Social Sciences Edition)， 2019， 19(5): 130-142.
[18] 高圆圆，陈哲. 农业产业化经营组织模式演化逻辑、效益比较与未来发展取向[J]. 贵州财经大学学报， 2022(5): 102-111.
Gao Yuanyuan， Chen Zhe. Evolution logic， benefit comparison and future development orientation of agricultural industrialization management organization mode [J]. Journal of Guizhou University of Finance and Economics， 2022(5): 102-111.
[19] 周立群，曹利群. 商品契约优于要素契约——以农业产业化经营中的契约选择为例[J]. 经济研究， 2002(1): 14-19.
Zhou Liqun， Cao Liqun. Factor contract is superior to commodity contract: Take the contract selection in agricultural industrialization management as an example [J]. Economic Research Journal， 2002(1): 14-19.
[20] 徐忠爱. 基于契约规制的农村经济组织模式研究[J]. 经济学家， 2010(2): 61-69.
Xu Zhong'ai. Research on rural economic organization model based on contractual rules [J]. Economist， 2010(2): 61-69.
[21] 尚旭东，叶云. 农业产业化联合体: 组织创新、组织异化、主体行为扭曲与支持政策取向[J]. 农村经济， 2020(3): 1-9.
Shang Xudong， Ye Yun. United entities of agricultural industrialization: Organizational innovation， organizational alienation， subject distorted behavior and selection for supporting policies [J]. Rural Economy， 2020(3): 1-9.
[22] 郭涛，赵德起. 中国现代农业经营体系发展水平测度及收入效应[J]. 山西财经大学学报， 2018， 40(10): 46-62.
Guo Tao， Zhao Deqi. Research on the development level measurement and income effect of modern agricultural management system in China [J]. Journal of Shanxi University of Finance and Economics， 2018， 40(10): 46-62.
[23] 刘源，王斌，朱炜. 纵向一体化模式与农业龙头企业价值实现——基于圣农和温氏的双案例研究[J]. 农业技术经济， 2019(10): 114-128.
Liu Yuan， Wang Bin， Zhu Wei. Vertical integration mode and value realization of agricultural leading enterprises: Based on the double case study analysis of sunner and wens [J]. Journal of Agro technical Economics， 2019(10): 114-128.
[24] 郑风田，崔梦怡，郭宇桥，等. 家庭农场领办合作社对农场绩效的影响——基于全国556个家庭农场两期追踪调查数据的实证分析[J]. 中国农村观察， 2022(5): 80-103.
Zheng Fengtian， Cui Mengyi， Guo Yuqiao， et al. The impact of family farm‑led cooperatives on farm performance: An analysis based on two‑phase tracking survey data of 556 family farms in China [J]. China Rural Survey， 2022(5): 80-103.
[25] 吴本健，肖时花，马九杰. 农业供给侧结构性改革背景下的农业产业化模式选择——基于三种契约关系的比较[J]. 经济问题探索， 2017(11): 183-190.
Wu Benjian， Xiao Shihua， Ma Jiujie. Selection of agricultural industrialization mode under the background of agricultural supply‑side structural reform: Based on the comparison of three contractual relations [J]. Inquiry into Economic Issues， 2017(11): 183-190.
[26] 钟真，蒋维扬，赵泽瑾. 农业产业化联合体的主要形式与运行机制——基于三个典型案例的研究[J]. 学习与探索， 2021(2): 91-101.
Zhong Zhen， Jiang Weiyang， Zhao Zejin. Main forms and operating mechanisms of agro‑industrial alliance: Based on research on three typical cases [J]. Study & Exploration， 2021(2): 91-101.
[27] Ferto I， Szabo G G. The choice of supply channels in the Hungarian fruit and vegetable sector‑a case study [J]. Kozgazdasagi Szemle Economic Review， 2004， 1(51): 77-89.
[28] 黄祖辉，张静， Chen Kevin. 交易费用与农户契约选择——来自浙冀两省15县30个村梨农调查的经验证据[J]. 管理世界， 2008(9): 76-81.
Huang Zuhui， Zhang Jing， Chen Kevin. Transaction costs and farmers selection of contracts: Empirical evidence from survey of pear farmers in 30 villages in 15 counties of Zhejiang and Hebei Provinces [J]. Journal of Management World， 2008(9): 76-81.
[29] 张康洁，吴国胜，尹昌斌，等. 绿色生产行为对稻农产业组织模式选择的影响——兼论收入效应[J]. 中国农业大学学报， 2021， 26(4): 225-239.
Zhang Kangjie， Wu Guosheng， Yin Changbin， et al. Influence of green production behavior on the industrial organization mode selection of rice farmers: Also on the income effect [J]. Journal of China Agricultural University， 2021， 26(4): 225-239.
[30] Dubbert C. Participation in contract farming and farm performance: Insights from cashew farmers in Ghana [J]. Agricultural Economics， 2019， 50(6): 749-763.
[31] 田露，张越杰. 肉牛产业链组织模式选择及其影响因素分析——基于河南等14个省份341个养殖户(场)的调查[J]. 中国农村经济， 2010(5): 56-64.
Tian Lu， Zhang Yuejie. Option for organizational modes in beef industrial chain and analysis of the determinants based on survey to 341 livestock farms in 14 Provinces [J]. Chinese Rural Economy， 2010(5): 56-64.
[32] 蔡荣，蔡书凯. 粮食主产区农户订单参与行为及交易绩效研究——以安徽省水稻种植户为例[J]. 财贸研究， 2013， 24(2): 29-36.
Cai Rong， Cai ShuKai. Farmers' participation behavior in contract and its benefit evaluation: Based on rice farmers in Anhui Province [J]. Finance and Trade Research， 2013， 24(2): 29-36.
[33] Miyata S， Minot N， Hu D. Impact of contract farming on income: Linking small farmers， packers， and supermarkets in China [J]. World development， 2009， 37(11): 1781-1790.
[34] Ragasa C， Lambrecht I， Kufoalor D S. Limitations of contract farming as a pro‑poor strategy: The case of maize outgrower schemes in upper west ghana [J]. World Development， 2018(102): 30-56.
[35] Barrett C B， Bachke M E， Bellemare M F， et al. Smallholder participation in contract farming: Comparative evidence from five countries [J]. World Development， 2012， 40(4): 715-730.
[36] 徐健，汪旭晖. 订单农业及其组织模式对农户收入影响的实证分析[J]. 中国农村经济， 2009(4): 39-47.
[37] 罗千峰，罗增海. 合作社再组织化的实现路径与增效机制——基于青海省三家生态畜牧业合作社的案例分析[J]. 中国农村观察， 2022(1): 91-106.
Luo Qianfeng， Luo Zenghai. Reorganization paths and efficiency mechanisms of cooperatives: An analysis based on the case study of three ecologicalanimal husbandry cooperatives in Qinghai Province [J]. China Rural Survey， 2022(1): 91-106.
[38] 张连刚，陈卓. 农民专业合作社提升了农户社会资本吗?——基于云南省506份农户调查数据的实证分析[J]. 中国农村观察， 2021(1): 106-121.
Zhang Liangang， Chen Zhuo. Do farmers' specialized cooperatives increase farmers' social capital? An analysis based on survey data from 506 farmers in Yunnan Province [J]. China Rural Survey， 2021(1): 106-121.
[39] 梁远，毕文泰，滕奎秀. 家庭资产、社会互动与农村居民主观幸福感[J]. 中国农业资源与区划， 2022， 43(8): 247-257.
Liang Yuan， Bi Wentai， Teng Kuixiu. Family assets， social interaction and subjective well‑being of rural residents [J]. Chinese Journal of Agricultural Resources and Regional Planning， 2022， 43(8): 247-257.
[40] 刘森挥，曹建民，张越杰. 农户组织模式与其技术效率的关系——一个考虑样本异质性的分析[J]. 农业技术经济， 2019(12): 68-79.
[41] 牛文浩，申淑虹，蔡孟洋，等. 农业产业组织能否影响农户安全生产行为——来自陕西省眉县500户猕猴桃种植户的证据[J]. 农业技术经济， 2022(1): 114-128.